The Man Who Wins Little Ones
(Originally published in Polk County News, November 23, 2005)
McCaysville, morning in a sunlit pasture. I watch as Dr. Bill Mitchell strokes the horse’s neck, murmurs into its upright ear—a secret, perhaps—and slips a needle through the glossy hair and under the skin. The horse nuzzles him, blinking shy brown eyes. Hot blood fills the sample tube.
We ride back to the Copper Basin Vet Clinic, the vial of blood cooling in the cup-holder between us, and Dr. Mitchell tells me, in his genteel Georgia drawl, why he left a three-decade career as a pathologist and veterinarian for the U.S. Army to come home and care for animals full-time.
“During Desert Storm I had to do autopsies, every day, every day, every day. And you’re doing autopsies on people that are perfectly healthy; the only bad thing is that they’ve been killed. And the thing that I could never—that always bothered me—I just couldn’t deal with their faces, with the expressions on their faces. It just got to me. And when I came back I said, ‘I’m not doing this anymore. I’m not dealing with humans any more.’ That was enough.”
When a man realizes he can’t win the big one, he tries to win a few of the little ones instead. At his clinic Dr. Mitchell leads me into his “rescue room,” a tragically crowded space in the back where he keeps the unwanted, the abandoned, the abused. Unweaned kittens claw a wire cage, malnourished dogs pace in kennels. And on a cushion in the corner lies a dog with long black hair, a white nose, and stumps where his hind legs once were. I stoop to pet him, to offer a little sympathy, but he cringes. This mutilated animal was a puppy once, a confident curious fuzzball; and now he whimpers at the sight of a human. I wonder: what horrible lesson has he learned about people? The same one Dr. Mitchell learned during Desert Storm?
The poor dog is a parable cast in fur and flesh; an appalling commentary on victimization. If Dr. Mitchell can no longer deal in human victims, he can still treat the victims of humans—or sub-humans, if you like—and as he and I sit in his waiting room and discuss his practice, I’m shaken.
Most people, thank God, don’t abuse animals, but Dr. Mitchell explains how pets can suffer even when owners and would-be caregivers have the best of intentions.
“I think that poor lady that had all these creatures up there, all these poor animals—” referring to the recent allegations of animal cruelty against Turtletown resident Maureen Vieira “—I think she had intentions of doing something good, but the sad part is, it turned out to be horrible. It was a horrible, horrible thing, and I wonder...what took so long for somebody to say, you know, that something needs to be done? Nobody did anything.”
He goes on to describe how economic circumstances in the Copper Basin can contribute to animal neglect. “What we have are people who are having a hard time making it. The boom days are long gone. The young people either have to find something here to do, or they’ve gotta leave. There’s no industry.”
“I deal with people who...are on a fixed income, that have to make a decision between food, and heat, and their animal. And the sad part is, a lot of these people, that’s their companion. There’s one veteran, he has this little dog, and his wife, of course, is in the nursing home. That dog is his companion, that’s his life, and if something happens to that dog, he’ll come in...and he’s just all to pieces. So I enjoy when I can do something.”
“You’re not making anything, but at least I do two things: I give jobs to people that need a job, plus I take care of some animals. I make enough that...ah...I think last year I lost a lot of money. This year, hopefully, I won’t lose so much.”
I don’t meet many business owners who are content to take a loss, but even Dr. Mitchell’s low fee structure is designed to benefit animals. His prices help some owners afford care, while bringing in others who might refuse the indignity of charity. So on Thanksgiving Day I guess Dr. Mitchell will thank the Army for providing the pension he uses to subsidize his little wins.
Some of his wins, though, aren’t so little. An exuberant Boxer named Rocky—yeah, it’s a bad pun—bounds into my lap and knocks my tape recorder clattering across the room. I remark on the aptness of the name; Rocky favors Sylvester Stallone, and Dr. Mitchell’s daughter Robbii surprises me by hauling Rocky’s mouth open to reveal his cleft palate. Robbii tells me Dr. Mitchell delivered Rocky by C-section from a dog show champion, accepting Rocky as his fee when he learned the champion’s breeder was planning to destroy Rocky in order to eradicate his genetic abnormality from her stock.
I’ve barely recovered from Rocky’s relentless affection when a Jack Russell mix named Little Girl explodes onto me, slinging slobber near and far. Dr. Mitchell smiles, reaches over to pet her. “This dog right here, I found her in a ditch. She was almost dead. I brought her down here and I put her on fluids and IVs, and I did all this stuff...I thought she was gonna die, but she survived. And ever since then, she’s been right under me.”
Right under him. Yeah, I can see why she’d want to be.
But an apparent contradiction occurs to me. As an Army pathologist he experimented on animals, studied tissue samples, tried to come up with ways to protect soldiers from anthrax and botulism. I ask if this bothers him now—why would an animal rescuer condone animal experimentation? His answer comes quickly, as if he’s known it since medical school.
“I’m a religious person. And when God made this earth, he made all the animals, and then he made man to take care of his animals. But he also made the animals to take care of man. It was a two-way street. When I look at research using animals...the animals are not being abused. They’re not being tortured. They’re making a gift back to us.”
“There are some really terrible human diseases. Spinal bifida. There’s an animal model for that, and that’s a Manx cat. By studying the genetic defect...the lethal gene, or whatever you want to call it...we can head off spinal bifida.” He goes on to describe how animal research is helping eradicate muscular dystrophy, and as he talks his manner is gentle, warm. Grateful, even. And I realize that not only does Dr. Mitchell help animals, but animals also help him.
When I get home from the clinic my family’s Scottish Terrier, Gracie, wiggles all over me. Then she backs off, sniffing me suspiciously as if I’ve been unfaithful to her with Rocky and Little Girl—how dare those tramps! My wife mentions she’s worried about Gracie’s breath. Maybe it’s a problem with her teeth?
“I know a good vet,” I say.
McCaysville, morning in a sunlit pasture. I watch as Dr. Bill Mitchell strokes the horse’s neck, murmurs into its upright ear—a secret, perhaps—and slips a needle through the glossy hair and under the skin. The horse nuzzles him, blinking shy brown eyes. Hot blood fills the sample tube.
We ride back to the Copper Basin Vet Clinic, the vial of blood cooling in the cup-holder between us, and Dr. Mitchell tells me, in his genteel Georgia drawl, why he left a three-decade career as a pathologist and veterinarian for the U.S. Army to come home and care for animals full-time.
“During Desert Storm I had to do autopsies, every day, every day, every day. And you’re doing autopsies on people that are perfectly healthy; the only bad thing is that they’ve been killed. And the thing that I could never—that always bothered me—I just couldn’t deal with their faces, with the expressions on their faces. It just got to me. And when I came back I said, ‘I’m not doing this anymore. I’m not dealing with humans any more.’ That was enough.”
When a man realizes he can’t win the big one, he tries to win a few of the little ones instead. At his clinic Dr. Mitchell leads me into his “rescue room,” a tragically crowded space in the back where he keeps the unwanted, the abandoned, the abused. Unweaned kittens claw a wire cage, malnourished dogs pace in kennels. And on a cushion in the corner lies a dog with long black hair, a white nose, and stumps where his hind legs once were. I stoop to pet him, to offer a little sympathy, but he cringes. This mutilated animal was a puppy once, a confident curious fuzzball; and now he whimpers at the sight of a human. I wonder: what horrible lesson has he learned about people? The same one Dr. Mitchell learned during Desert Storm?
The poor dog is a parable cast in fur and flesh; an appalling commentary on victimization. If Dr. Mitchell can no longer deal in human victims, he can still treat the victims of humans—or sub-humans, if you like—and as he and I sit in his waiting room and discuss his practice, I’m shaken.
Most people, thank God, don’t abuse animals, but Dr. Mitchell explains how pets can suffer even when owners and would-be caregivers have the best of intentions.
“I think that poor lady that had all these creatures up there, all these poor animals—” referring to the recent allegations of animal cruelty against Turtletown resident Maureen Vieira “—I think she had intentions of doing something good, but the sad part is, it turned out to be horrible. It was a horrible, horrible thing, and I wonder...what took so long for somebody to say, you know, that something needs to be done? Nobody did anything.”
He goes on to describe how economic circumstances in the Copper Basin can contribute to animal neglect. “What we have are people who are having a hard time making it. The boom days are long gone. The young people either have to find something here to do, or they’ve gotta leave. There’s no industry.”
“I deal with people who...are on a fixed income, that have to make a decision between food, and heat, and their animal. And the sad part is, a lot of these people, that’s their companion. There’s one veteran, he has this little dog, and his wife, of course, is in the nursing home. That dog is his companion, that’s his life, and if something happens to that dog, he’ll come in...and he’s just all to pieces. So I enjoy when I can do something.”
“You’re not making anything, but at least I do two things: I give jobs to people that need a job, plus I take care of some animals. I make enough that...ah...I think last year I lost a lot of money. This year, hopefully, I won’t lose so much.”
I don’t meet many business owners who are content to take a loss, but even Dr. Mitchell’s low fee structure is designed to benefit animals. His prices help some owners afford care, while bringing in others who might refuse the indignity of charity. So on Thanksgiving Day I guess Dr. Mitchell will thank the Army for providing the pension he uses to subsidize his little wins.
Some of his wins, though, aren’t so little. An exuberant Boxer named Rocky—yeah, it’s a bad pun—bounds into my lap and knocks my tape recorder clattering across the room. I remark on the aptness of the name; Rocky favors Sylvester Stallone, and Dr. Mitchell’s daughter Robbii surprises me by hauling Rocky’s mouth open to reveal his cleft palate. Robbii tells me Dr. Mitchell delivered Rocky by C-section from a dog show champion, accepting Rocky as his fee when he learned the champion’s breeder was planning to destroy Rocky in order to eradicate his genetic abnormality from her stock.
I’ve barely recovered from Rocky’s relentless affection when a Jack Russell mix named Little Girl explodes onto me, slinging slobber near and far. Dr. Mitchell smiles, reaches over to pet her. “This dog right here, I found her in a ditch. She was almost dead. I brought her down here and I put her on fluids and IVs, and I did all this stuff...I thought she was gonna die, but she survived. And ever since then, she’s been right under me.”
Right under him. Yeah, I can see why she’d want to be.
But an apparent contradiction occurs to me. As an Army pathologist he experimented on animals, studied tissue samples, tried to come up with ways to protect soldiers from anthrax and botulism. I ask if this bothers him now—why would an animal rescuer condone animal experimentation? His answer comes quickly, as if he’s known it since medical school.
“I’m a religious person. And when God made this earth, he made all the animals, and then he made man to take care of his animals. But he also made the animals to take care of man. It was a two-way street. When I look at research using animals...the animals are not being abused. They’re not being tortured. They’re making a gift back to us.”
“There are some really terrible human diseases. Spinal bifida. There’s an animal model for that, and that’s a Manx cat. By studying the genetic defect...the lethal gene, or whatever you want to call it...we can head off spinal bifida.” He goes on to describe how animal research is helping eradicate muscular dystrophy, and as he talks his manner is gentle, warm. Grateful, even. And I realize that not only does Dr. Mitchell help animals, but animals also help him.
When I get home from the clinic my family’s Scottish Terrier, Gracie, wiggles all over me. Then she backs off, sniffing me suspiciously as if I’ve been unfaithful to her with Rocky and Little Girl—how dare those tramps! My wife mentions she’s worried about Gracie’s breath. Maybe it’s a problem with her teeth?
“I know a good vet,” I say.
